The measured ranking
"Share of answers" = the percentage of the 138 answered question × engine checks in which the tool is named. "First named" = how many times it is the first tool mentioned in an answer.
| Tool | Share of answers | First named | Strongest engine | Weakest engine | Public pricing (Nov 16) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Otterly | 51% | 31× | Gemini 73% | ChatGPT 27% | from €29/mo |
| 2. Semrush (AI features) | 47% | 17× | Gemini 80% | ChatGPT 20% | suite subscription |
| 3. Profound | 44% | 32× | Gemini 80% | ChatGPT 17% | none — demo only |
| 4. Peec AI | 43% | 5× | Gemini 73% | ChatGPT 23% | from $95/mo |
| 5. Ahrefs (AI features) | 31% | 13× | Gemini 47% | Claude 10% | suite subscription |
| 6. Scrunch | 9% | 1× | — | — | — |
| 7. Rankscale | 6% | 1× | — | — | — |
| 8. Brand24 | 4% | 5× | — | — | — |
| 9. Knowatoa | 1% | 0× | — | — | — |
| 10. Ainswer (us) | 0% | 0× | — | — | free scan · $500 diagnostic · $200/mo |
Mention counting is exact name-token matching, case-sensitive. One product ("Mention") was excluded — its name is an ordinary English word and cannot be counted reliably. "Profound" may be slightly overcounted for the same reason; treat it as an upper bound.
Which tool fits which buyer
Otterly — the measured category leader
Named in more answers than any other dedicated tool, and the only top-3 tool with transparent entry pricing (Lite €29/mo for 16 prompts; Standard €189/mo for 120; Premium €489/mo, verified Nov 16, 2026). Daily tracking, citation sources, free trial. If you want the tool AI itself most often names, this is currently it. See Otterly alternatives if its prompt-based pricing doesn't fit.
Profound — enterprise, sales-led
The most often first-named tool in our scan (32×) and strong with agencies and mid-market. No published pricing — a free trial exists, everything else goes through a demo call. If you need procurement-friendly self-serve pricing, look elsewhere.
Peec AI — the fast riser
Went from absent in our September scan to 43% of answers in November — the fastest entry we have measured in any category. Starter $95/mo covers 50 prompts on 3 engine models of your choice; extra models cost $30–140/mo depending on plan (verified Nov 16, 2026). See the three-way comparison.
Semrush / Ahrefs — the suite option
If you already pay for either suite, their AI-visibility features are the zero-friction start — and AI engines recommend Semrush for this category more often than any specialist except Otterly. The trade-off: AI visibility is a feature, not the product; check engine coverage (especially Google AI Overviews and Claude) against a dedicated tool before deciding.
Ainswer — us, the 0% row
Five engines including Google AI Overviews (which has no public API — we obtain it through location-targeted search data), multi-run consensus on every check, citation tracking with a source-level to-do list, and native Traditional Chinese / Asian-market question sets. Free first scan with no email, $500 one-time diagnostic, $200/mo monitoring. The row above is our own scanner telling the truth about us: AI does not recommend us yet, and we publish the number weekly rather than hide it. If that kind of measurement is what you want pointed at your own brand, run the free scan.
How to choose (the 10-minute test)
- Engines: engines disagree hugely — category leaders here score 73–80% on Gemini and 17–27% on ChatGPT. A tool covering only chat engines, or missing Google AI Overviews, will tell you a confident, partial story.
- Multi-run: ask any vendor how many times they run each question. Across our studies roughly 15% of answers flip between identical runs; single-pass tools cannot separate your progress from noise.
- Citations: the difference between a score and a to-do list is seeing which sources fed each answer — and which of them never mention you.
- Your language and market: if your buyers ask in another language, the questions must be asked in that language, in that market.
- Raw answers: any tool should show you the actual answer text behind every number. If it can't, the number can't be checked.
Method, data & disclosure
- Ranking data: 30 buyer-style questions about AI-visibility / AEO tools, US market, English, run Nov 16, 2026 through ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude and Google AI Overviews, multi-run with consensus. 138 of 150 checks returned answers (Google AI Overviews answered 18 of 30 questions). Full tables, the 60-day trend and citation analysis are in the companion report.
- Pricing and plan facts were read from each vendor's public pricing page on Nov 16, 2026 and describe their claims, not our testing. Prices change; check the vendor's site.
- Disclosure: Ainswer is a product in this category. This page is a competitor's writing — which is exactly why the ranking is a published, re-runnable measurement instead of our opinion, and why our own product sits last in it.
- This page is updated when we re-scan. Ranking date is shown at the top.
Measure your own brand the same way.
Paste your site — one real buyer question across five engines, free, no email. See whether AI recommends you, and which sources feed the answers when it doesn't.