Head-to-head, measured
| Otterly | Profound | Peec AI | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Named in AI answers (overall) | 51% | 44% | 43% |
| First tool named | 31× | 32× | 5× |
| ChatGPT | 27% | 17% | 23% |
| Perplexity | 50% | 50% | 50% |
| Gemini | 73% | 80% | 73% |
| Claude | 43% | 33% | 33% |
| Google AI Overviews | 67% | 39% | 33% |
| Trend since Sep 2026 | rising (ChatGPT 6%→25%) | flat | new entrant → 43% |
| Entry pricing (verified Nov 16) | €29/mo · 16 prompts | not published | $95/mo · 50 prompts · 3 engines |
| Pricing model | prompts + credits | demo / sales-led | prompts + pick-your-engines |
| Free trial | yes | yes | yes |
Percentages = share of answered checks naming the tool, per engine (30 questions, multi-run consensus, US market, Nov 16, 2026). Google AI Overviews answered 18 of 30 questions. Pricing from vendor sites, same date.
What the numbers say
Otterly is the breadth leader. Highest overall share, strongest on Google AI Overviews (67%) and Claude (43%), and the clearest upward trend — in our September scan ChatGPT named it in 6% of answers; by November, 25%. It also has the lowest verified entry price of the three.
Profound is the prominence leader. Slightly lower overall share, but the most often named first — 32 times, edging Otterly's 31 — and tied or ahead on Gemini (80%). Pair that with its demo-only sales motion and the picture is consistent: an enterprise product with enterprise positioning.
Peec AI is the momentum story. It did not appear once in our September scan; in November it is named in 43% of answers and matches the other two on Perplexity and Gemini. Its weakness is prominence (first-named only 5 times) — engines list it, but rarely lead with it. Pricing is mid-pack with an unusual lever: you choose which 3 engine models you pay to track.
The quick decision
- Small team, want transparent pricing, broad engines: Otterly.
- Enterprise or agency, have a procurement process, want the premium motion: Profound.
- Know exactly which 2–3 engines matter to you, want flexibility: Peec AI.
- Need Google AI Overviews + multi-run consensus + citation to-do lists, or a Traditional Chinese / Asian market: that's the gap we built Ainswer for ($200/mo, free first scan) — with the standing caveat that AI engines currently recommend us in 0% of this category's answers, a number we measure and publish ourselves.
Method, data & disclosure
- Measurement: 30 buyer questions × 5 engines, US market, English, multi-run consensus, Nov 16, 2026; 138 of 150 checks answered. Mention counting is exact name-token matching; "Profound" is counted case-sensitively and may be slightly overcounted (the adjective) — treat its figures as an upper bound. September baseline is the published table in report #002.
- Pricing and trial facts read from each vendor's public site on Nov 16, 2026 — vendors' claims, not our product testing. We have not run these three products.
- Disclosure: Ainswer competes with all three. Every comparative statement on this page is a dated measurement or a dated pricing fact, so you can check us.
Run the same measurement on your brand.
One real buyer question across five engines, free, no email — see who AI names when your buyers ask, and which sources fed the answer.