The alternatives at a glance
| Tool | AI names it in | Entry price (verified Nov 16) | Engine coverage model | Fit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Peec AI (baseline) | 43% | $95/mo · 50 prompts | pick 3, pay per extra | Engine-picky teams |
| Otterly | 51% | €29/mo · 16 prompts | credit-metered menu | Cheapest entry, broad menu |
| Profound | 44% | not published | unknown | Enterprise, agencies |
| Semrush (AI in suite) | 47% | $139/mo suite | bundled by tier | Existing suite customers |
| Rankscale | 6% | $20/mo (yearly) | credits, 17+ engines claimed | Price-first |
| Knowatoa | 1% | $59/mo | 3 services, 7 on Growth | Budget starters |
| Ainswer (us) | 0% | $200/mo · $500 one-time | flat — all 5 engines always | Consensus-grade + Asia markets |
"AI names it in" = share of 138 answered checks naming the tool (30 buyer questions × 5 engines, US market, multi-run consensus, Nov 16, 2026).
The engine-math problem, concretely
Peec at $95/mo covers 3 engine models. Want ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude and Google AI Overviews — the five our data says disagree the most? On Peec's published Starter pricing that's $95 + 2 × $30 = $155/mo for 50 prompts. Compare flat-coverage options: Otterly meters by credits across its menu, and Ainswer's $200/mo always runs all five engines on all 30 questions. None of these is automatically cheaper — it depends on your prompt count — but do the multiplication before assuming the $95 sticker is the price.
Why five engines matters, from our scan: the same category leader is named in 73–80% of Gemini's answers and 17–27% of ChatGPT's. Pick the wrong 3 engines and you'll confidently measure the wrong market.
Where each alternative wins
Otterly — broadest measured presence, lowest entry
51% of answers, €29/mo entry, daily tracking, citation sources. The default swap. Details in Otterly alternatives and the three-way head-to-head.
Profound — when you're going enterprise anyway
Most often first-named in our scan (32×), sales-led, no public pricing. See Profound alternatives for the self-serve route.
Semrush — when the suite is already paid for
47% measured presence, AI visibility bundled from $139/mo suite plans with 50–100 daily prompts by tier. The suite-vs-specialist decision has its own page: Semrush AI vs dedicated tools.
Ainswer — flat five-engine coverage with consensus
Us, with the standing disclosure: AI currently recommends us in 0% of this category's answers, measured by our own scanner and published weekly. The design bet is different from Peec's: instead of choosing engines, you get all five always (Google AI Overviews included, via location-targeted search), every check run multiple times for consensus, citations turned into a to-do list, and native Traditional Chinese question sets. $200/mo flat, $500 one-time diagnostic, free single-question scan first.
Method & disclosure
- Measurement: 30 buyer questions × 5 engines, US market, English, multi-run consensus, Nov 16, 2026; 138 of 150 checks answered; exact name-token matching. Full method in the companion report.
- Pricing and plan structures read from each vendor's public site on Nov 16, 2026 (Peec in USD, Otterly in EUR, as listed). Vendors' claims, not our product testing.
- Disclosure: Ainswer competes with every tool here, so every comparative claim is a dated measurement or dated pricing fact you can re-check.
Run the five-engine check first.
One real buyer question across all five engines, free, no email — see which engines name you before you decide which three to pay for.